Friday 13 October 2017

Are these spots on the sensor or the lens?




Equipment is Canon EOS 5D3 (5760x3840) with a 24-105 f/4 L lens at 105mm, ISO 200.


The following are crops from the same small (676x449) section of a couple of blue sky shots I did to test for sensor dirt. The first image is unmodified other than Raw->JPEG conversion in Lightroom with no setting changes, and shows some faint dark circles.



f/22 unedited


To enhance the circles I cranked up contrast and clarity to 100%, giving this:



f/22 contrast-enhanced


However, the same area of an image taken 1 second earlier at f/7.1 shows no evidence of these spots, even after cranking up the contrast/clarity to 100%.




f/7.1 contrast-enhanced




  1. The spots seem to be more prevalent towards the edges of the original (full-size) image, although there is one spot near the center. None of the spots are visible at f/7.1.

  2. All the spots appear to be the same size, but have different densities.


Given all this evidence can I deduce that these are lens defects (or dirt on a lens element)?


Since they're completely undetectable at "normal" apertures I don't consider this a problem. I just would like to know what I'm seeing.


BTW, the obvious test is to shoot the same image with a different lens and compare, but I won't be able to do that for several days and thought this might be an interesting question for photo.se.





No comments:

Post a Comment

Why is the front element of a telephoto lens larger than a wide angle lens?

A wide angle lens has a wide angle of view, therefore it would make sense that the front of the lens would also be wide. A telephoto lens ha...